Rukhaiyar's Corner

  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • General
    • Education
    • Society
    • Economy
    • Politics
    • Defence
    • History
    • IT Sector
  • Internet
    • SEO
    • Domain
    • Hosting
    • Apps
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Contact Us

Could Gandhi have Withstood the Taliban

December 26, 2010 by Abhishek Rukhaiyar Leave a Comment

On July 23rd 2007, one of the grandsons of Mahatma Gandhi said that INDIAN nationalist leader Mahatma Gandhi would have “stood up to” the Taliban and Osama bin Laden if he were alive today. He told the BBC his grandfather would also have tried to organise “something dramatic” – perhaps a mass fast – to show how unhappy most Muslims were that their religion was being linked to terrorism. This is just a speculation that Mahatma Gandhi would have stood against the Taliban. But, even if would have, whether it would be effective or not is the thing to discuss.

Mahatma Gandhi became a national hero after he successfully led the black South Africans and Indians in South Africa against discrimination. He is remembered for his effort in the independence of India. The main power of Mahatma Gandhi was Satyagrah.

This is defined as resistance to tyranny through mass civil disobedience, a philosophy firmly founded upon ahimsa, or total nonviolence. This tool worked very well against British. But, there are doubts that it would have worked against Taliban too.

As the tool used by Mahatma Gandhi was based upon civil disobedience, the acts of Mahatma Gandhi used to impact British Raj deeply. No government could withstand against public, and Mahatma Gandhi used public power for all his campaigns. Now, the situation with Taliban is different. Taliban is a Hanafi Islamist political Group which governed Afghanistan from 1996 until it was overthrown in late 2001. Main ideology of Taliban moved a lot around Sharia Law. Sharia is the sacred law of Islam. As it is related to religion, public support is much more with them than with the British in India. So, using civil disobedience against Taliban could not work. As the power of the mass would not be with him and without the mass of Afghanistan nothing much could have been done. Even if Muslims around the globe feel ashamed of Taliban, their cooperation could not work to dismantle Taliban. So, the main weapon of Mahatma Gandhi would have failed in this scenario.

As much we know Mahatma Gandhi, we may expect that he may have discovered some other non-violence technique to fight against Taliban. But, we can just do presumptions. But, based on the life work of Mahatma Gandhi we can conclude that He could not have withstood the Taliban.

Filed Under: History, Society Tagged With: Gandhi, Non-violence, Taliban

Selling Liquor in a Gandhian State is an Anomaly

December 20, 2010 by Abhishek Rukhaiyar 1 Comment

Gandhi, the father of our nation, was strongly against the selling and drinking of liquors. He used to say, it is criminal to spend the income from the sale of intoxicants on the education of the nation’s children or other public services. The government must overcome the temptation of using such revenue for nation-building purposes.

India has come a long way ahead of the state of 1930s or 40s. The poverty level and situation have changed. In 30s, people in the state of unemployment and poverty used to spend their spare time in drinking, even if they had no money. The result was families destroyed due to head of the family being indulged in drinking habit. Violence caused by drinking problem was a common thing at that time. That’s why; Mr. Gandhi had to address the nation about drinking practice.

As Gandhi should be our ideal and our nation should reflect to follow his principles. After independence India should had to abolish the selling of liquor. But no, India is still generating revenues from liquor. Now, the thing is whether drinking liquor is actually bad habit or it was the situation which demands Mr. Gandhi to be against liquor.

According to the NIAAA – National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, it concluded, after much scientific reviews that moderate drinkers do have lowest death rate compare to heavy drinkers and some fellows who don’t drink. In another word, if you take liquor as a drug and take in a controlled fashion; it is good for your health and longevity. So, being strictly against the liquor or drinking habit is quick or biased judgement. Excess of anything is not good. So is the case with liquor too.

Human beings have a general tendency or affinity for intoxication. The form may be different but everyone loves to do it. When someone gets bored of their hard social life, they turn to things which can let them forget everything for some time. Either it is in the form of drinking, gaming, chatting, swimming or playing badminton after work. The motto is only one, to forget everything for some moment. It just depends on them which form attracts them. But, in the present world everyone is trying to get refreshed by one of such forms.

One may say that there are people who turn violent after drinking. But, overdose of every drugs have side-effects. Even overdose of sleeping pills. But then again, to avoid such cases there should be strict guidelines for over drinking. Also, a lot of accidents occur every year due to an alcoholic driver. Nevertheless, still it’s a case of over drinking.

Therefore, stopping the sale of liquor is not a solution. It is true that we live in a Gandhian state. But, it does not mean we should stop applying things which were true in his period. Selling liquor in a Gandhian state is not an anomaly at all.

Filed Under: Society Tagged With: drinking, Gandhi, india, liquor

Is Sonia Gandhi Eligible To Become The Prime Minister?

May 17, 2010 by Abhishek Rukhaiyar Leave a Comment

SG

Can She Be An Indian PM

As the election campaign is drawing to its close (April-May 2004) the issue of Sonia Gandhi being suitable or not for Prime Minister-ship due to her being a foreigner are coming out once again. Here one is not talking of her suitability for holding the top place in Indian administration but is restricting to the point whether Indian Citizens, whose place of birth does not happen to be in India are eligible for such a post or not? Needless to say
this issue is being raked up since Sonia Gandhi first joined the Congress and has been contender for the top job in the country. Needless to say this also reflects the bankruptcy of the electoral campaign in a country, which is riddled with infinite problems for the poor masses irrespective of its being shining for a minuscule section of the society. It also hides the fact that those raising it can twist the logic the other way around when it suits their own electoral needs.

The latest argument being put forward is that giving the sensitive posts to such people may be a security risk. In between the same argument has been extended to other posts apart from the one of Prime minister. In between the argument was also put forward that the children of such citizens also are not eligible for the top jobs. For those raising this issue, it is not much of their concern about what does constitution says on this. It is not of much concern here that people have accepted whole-heartedly, such people through the electoral system. Lately, Amma (Jayalalitha) has come forward to ask that is there not a single Indian capable for such a post, that we have to look at a foreigner to lead the country? It must be pointed out that two words are used interchangeably here, the word foreigner and the word person of foreign origin.

Talking of Sonia Gandhi, she has been the main target of such snipers. Initially it was also said that the work of conversion being carried on is also drawing support from her. Her connections with Italy are ridiculed by posing the alternative between Ram Rajya and Rome Rajya. The mudslinging has no end and bucket full of muck can be smeared on this issue. How does a country decide this point in a globalised world?

One recalls that there is a great joy and celebration when we hear about the person of Indian origin holding top jobs in other countries. There are small countries where the people of Indian origin have held the top job. Bobby Jindal’s surge for the medium level job was a matter of three or four cheers in Indian media and psyche. While talking about the people who were born in other parts of the world but adopted this country for their major commitment one recalls the likes of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, Annie Beasant and Mother Teresa to be the shining examples in this category. Even the worst of communist would not have objected to Maulana Azad holding the post of Indian National Congress or than becoming the education minister just because he was not born in this part of the land.

Where does one draw the cut off date? A person of Indian origin in the proper sense of the word is the current dictator of Pakistan, and had been the most hated name just prior to the cricket series. Currently, a person of Pakistani origin happens to hold the post of Deputy Prime minister in India.

Today there are some countries where their constitution says that only person who has been born in that country can be Prime minister or President. There are also countries where such a norm does not prevail. Our constitution does not hold any prescription about he place of birth of the citizen. Citizenship is the criterion for holding the top posts. To begin with those saying that being born in this land is a must, are saying something, which violates the Indian constitution. Any way the people of Sangh combine, who began it all, have no respect for this constitution, as this constitution has emerged from the freedom struggle, due to India becoming a modern nation-state through the anti-British struggle, with which they had nothing whatsoever to do. They are itching with all their might to do away with this and are waiting in the wings to do so. None other than RSS supremo K.Sudarshan went on to say the same.

Other politicos, like Sharad Pawar and Amma, those who have picked up the cue initially thrown in the circuit by RSS progeny, are doing so in a purely opportunistic way. Sharad Pawar who broke away from the Congress on this ground did come back to ally with the same party for electoral reasons. Amma and others again are playing the role of holier than thou, lacking other political issues they are trying to make an issue out of it. It can whip up emotions of the society, that’s for sure. This politics like the one of Ram temple movement is a sort of one based on emotional pitch.

Is being a citizen not good enough for holding any post of the people find you fit enough for that? The transnational movement of people across the countries is on the rise. Many of those of Indian origin are active in the politics in other countries. Sonia Gandhi or no Sonia Gandhi, the guidance should be derived from the constitution. We have multitude of examples of Islāmic countries, where fundamentalism prevails, where the concept of citizenship is modulated according to the whims of the ruling coterie. Taliban in Afghanistan during their brief tenure did dictate about how people of different religions should wear and behave.

In our own country books of Golwalkar and Savarkar have given the guidelines about the status and ranking of citizenship according to their religion. Savarkar defines the citizen on the ground of one’s Holy land and Father land. Golwalkar calls Christians and Muslims as Foreign races. If we keep going back in time the results will be disastrous. Mahatma Jotiba Phule calls the Aryans as the invaders, and thereby foreigners. In Sri Lanka, the dominant Buddhists called themselves as the first comers and so having a bigger ownership of the country. Golwalkar also says that the country is of the Hindu race, and the Muslims and Christians, who as they are foreigners, should have no citizenship rights. When this was being written large section of Muslims and Christians were participating in the process of building of India as a nation-state through the struggle for freedom, along with the Hindus and people of all the religions of the country.

Where will the logic of all this takes us is any body’s guess. The politics should work within the constitutional limits, it should be purged of the emotive content so that the real issues of the people are to the fore and there by headway can be made for a more egalitarian society, a society where the concept of human rights is the final arbiter of social and political norms.

Filed Under: Politics Tagged With: Gandhi, india, Prime Minister, Sonia Gandhi

Recent Posts

  • Easy WordPress-NGINX Configuration – EasyEngine
  • Examination – Has It Killed Education?
  • Organic Foods: Are They Worth The Hype
  • Introduction From Basic: What is WordPress?
  • How Good Are The New IITs

Recent Comments

  • Abhishek Rukhaiyar on JEE: Should I Take A Drop?
  • kiara on JEE: Should I Take A Drop?
  • nobin on When Should I Start Preparing for IIT?
  • nobin on When Should I Start Preparing for IIT?
  • Abhishek Rukhaiyar on IIT JEE: What should be the strategy for repeaters?

Design

With an emphasis on typography, white space, and mobile-optimized design, your website will look absolutely breathtaking.

Learn more about design.

Copyright © 2026 · Sixteen Nine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in